ICANN to critics: we’ve by now done pilot TLD rounds

ICANN states it’s done three pilot rounds of top level domain expansion.

A frequent complaint regarding ICANN’s fresh top level domain plans in recent months is the scale, with numerous groups asking ICANN to run a pilot program.

But in response to an FTC query, ICANN has faced this issue head on by pointing out something obvious: it has by now run “pilot” rounds.

1. 2000 proof of concept round which approved seven fresh TLDs

2. 2004 sponsored top level domain program

3. 2009 IDN fast track that has by now generated 30 IDN ccTLDs

ICANN states it learned notable lessons in these rounds of TLD expansion. First, TLDs can safely be added to the internet. Second, placing limits on the number of TLDs approved or the type (sponsored) puts ICANN in a position of picking winners and losers. It also leads to gaming by people that try to fit into the mold required to be approved.

The letter to the FTC also subtly reminds the commission that there are by now 300 top level domain names on the web — many more than the 22 often cited by critics.